“Kinism” is a term seldom heard in Canada, but south of the border it has made some inroads in Reformed circles including the CRC, and some that might even otherwise be called conservative Reformed. So this article is a watchman-on-the-wall bulletin, hoping it doesn’t hop north, but providing a brief heads-up so that the forewarned can be forearmed.
All self-described kinists support racial segregation in some form or fashion. Larry Ball puts it this way:
“Some Kinists believe that interracial marriage is sinful. I call this Heavy Kinism. Other Kinists believe that interracial marriage is not sinful, but unwise. I call this Light Kinism.”
Heavy or light, that sounds similar to something I’d expect from racist organizations like the Ku Klux Klan. But kinist Joel Webbon argues he is not racist because he’s not trying to elevate one race over another.
Are cultures to be preserved?
In fact, he argues his case against interracial marriage while expressing admiration for other cultures and ethnicities. He explains that the reason he wouldn’t want his daughter marrying someone Chinese or black is not because he thinks less of such men, but because it’s always been God’s intention for there to be separate peoples, cultures, nations, and ethnicities. And if we all intermarried, then wouldn’t those wonderful other cultures and peoples disappear? So, his argument goes, it’s for the preservation of these blessed distinctions that we shouldn’t intermarry.
Biblical passages kinists point to include:
- The Table of Nations in Genesis 10, and God’s scattering of people at the Tower of Babel in Genesis 11, which detail God’s hand in starting the different nations.
- God’s prohibition against intermarrying with other nations in Deuteronomy 7:1-4, Joshua 23:12–13, Judges 3:6, and so on.
- Acts 17:26 where God says He was the one to mark out the boundaries of the nations.
Practical problems
Of course, cultures change, and some really should. Should we preserve or oppose the Pharaoh worship of ancient Egypt? Or the martyring of Christians by the Roman Empire? Or the much higher than average fatherlessness of American black culture? Kinists want to preserve cultures, but Christians should understand that cultures can be weighed and evaluated. Some, like the current death culture of the West, celebrating the “right” of abortion, and the “autonomy” of euthanasia, need to be rejected, not protected.
National boundaries change too. So if these texts tell us nations need to be preserved, what of the North America before Europeans arrived? Or the communism of the old Soviet bloc? Did those cultures and nations and peoples need to be preserved? And if not them, why not them? And why others instead?
Here in North America, where the majority of the population has ethnicities that divide in countless directions, it’s all the more curious Webbon would push this point. Which of the countless mixed and mashed up cultures need to be protected from being intermixed? My own children come from a pretty mono-cultural background, and yet still have some Frisian, Dutch, Canadian, and American all thrown together. Do they need to marry someone with these same ethnic ratios? That might be a hard match to come by.
Still, the complexities of North American ethnicity are a practical objection to kinism, and we shouldn’t stop there. After all, kinists make their own practical case too. They point out that it could be smoother to marry someone who comes from the same background you do. If you marry someone from the same town, who attends the same church, and whose family and friends you already know, then you probably won’t get hit with too many surprises. That’s not true of someone you meet who comes from halfway around the world.
While that might be true, it doesn’t make any sort of case against interracial marriage. What it does highlight is the need for such a couple to have more deliberate discussions about what matters most, like God, what He says about headship, how many kids you each hope for, and where and how you want to live. And because assumptions can sometimes turn out to be wrong, these are good conversations to have even with someone who grew up just a few streets down. The importance of really talking things through before getting too serious might actually be a point in favor of interracial marriage, since in those circumstances the need for these discussions is all the more obvious.
What does the Bible say?
But, that’s all the practical points, and what do they matter compared to what God has to say? So, again, what’s the biblical response to kinism?
First, let’s address the texts that Webbon and others cite. Those that describe what God has done in setting up nations don’t actually serve up any prescription for what we should do. They describe but don’t prescribe – there is no command given. We also learn, via the example of Ruth and Rahab, that while Israelites weren’t to marry unbelievers, foreigners could marry into Israel if they followed the Lord.
We see also:
- God’s Word speaks to the Church being made up of every tribe and nation (Rev. 5:9, Matt. 28:19, etc.) so, on the one hand, there are many nations, but what matters is the unity of God’s people in Christ.
- That unity is even biological. While there are some minor differences between the “races” (to note one, Kenyans seem to be better long distance runners than, say Australian pygmies), everyone has a common parentage, first via Adam and Eve, and then later again, through Noah and his family.
- As Ruslan KD points out in his debate with Joel Webbon when Moses marries a Cushite woman in Numbers 12, Miriam and Aaron speak against it and they get punished, not him. Ruth the Moabite and Rahab the Canaanite are foreigners who are part of Jesus’ bloodline. “These are not fringe stories. They’re redemptive history moments.”
- 2 Corinthians 6:14 further clarifies that God forbids, not interracial marriage, but interfaith – we shouldn’t be “unequally yoked” with unbelievers.
As Ruslan KD also notes:
“In the New Testament, we see multiple epistles uh written to mixed ethnic churches. We see Corinth, we see Ephesus, Galatia, Colossae. These churches were ethnically and culturally mixed. We even see Paul writing to Timothy who was culturally and ethnically mixed. And what we see in Scripture, clear as day, is a rebuke of sexual immorality. We see a clear uh rebuke of idolatry. We see a clear rebuke of partiality. And of course a clear rebuke of false gospels. But we never ever not once do we see any rebuke of interethnic marriage. Not one. So if it is generally against God’s design, the silence of Scripture and the apostles is inexplicable.”
Thankfully kinism doesn’t seem to be a thing in Canada, at least yet, and my hope is that this heads up will be a help in keeping it from becoming so.
Reading in is all too common
Another reason to pay attention is to consider the type of argumentation offered. The kinist side has arguments that seem to be based on the Bible. After all, they look at how God has acted through history in establishing nations. But these are simply descriptions of what God has done, and not prescriptions for how He wants us to act. They are simply guessing at the why behind what God has done, and turning their guess into a guideline. Meanwhile, the other side is focused on what God has actually prescribed in His Word – what He has actually commanded. It’s the difference between eisegesis and exegesis, between reading our thoughts into the text, or trying to draw out what God has said.
So even if this debate doesn’t touch you or anyone you know, it’s worth some attention simply to help us see through arguments that masquerade as biblical but simply aren’t.