Real Talk: Mental health, sin & suffering

Real Talk: Mental health, sin & suffering

Share:
A A

This episode can also be found on your favorite podcast platform: Spotify, Apple, Podbean, Amazon Music or on our website. Be sure to subscribe to our YouTube channel and our podcast profiles so you can be notified when new episodes are released. Please note that the transcript below was automatically generated and lightly edited so it may contain some errors.

Tyler Vanderwoude
Have we gone from ignoring suffering to obsessing over it? For generations, Christians may have been too quick to tell people to toughen up and move on. But have we now swung too far the other direction, where our feelings, our thoughts, and our struggles can become the focus of our lives? Could some of what we call mental health struggles also reveal spiritual struggles or sin in our lives, and how do we take genuine mental health struggles seriously while still understanding that suffering is a part of living in a broken world? Today we’re talking to Dr. Mike Strating, a clinical psychologist and professor at Redeemer University. Mike is a deep thinker who, in some ways, is charting a new path in how we think about Christian psychology, mental health, and what it means to suffer and face our struggles without losing sight of who we are in Christ.
Let’s just dive right into it.

Dr. Mike Strating
Sounds good.

TV
So you’re Dr. Mike Strating now.

Dr. MS
Dr. Mike Strating. Since the last time we’ve seen each other, probably.

TV
Yeah, we can’t figure out when that was. But Mike’s a year older than me. We went through high school, you know, kind of together-ish. But yeah, we just yeah, kind of known you from way back when, mostly as a goalie in hockey that I couldn’t score on. So that’s it’s a lot of fun. So yeah, I guess tell our listeners how you became a doctor of psychology because we’re going to talk about psychology today and some counseling, and we’re going to talk about mental health. So, what brought you down the road – however many years we are out of high school – to where you are today.

Dr. MS
Yeah, that’s a very long story. So I’ll try to give you the short version of the story. Yeah. So growing up in in high school, I was never one of those kids who knew what I wanted to do for a career kind of a thing, right? Didn’t know from kindergarten I wanted to be a firefighter, and that was, you know, where I was off to, right? And I knew I wanted to help people, and that was, and I liked math and science. So I was really trying to put those things together. So had some aspirations of becoming a family doctor potentially, and so I started in a biology program at university in my undergrad, and that’s where I actually began. But didn’t find it was a great fit for what I was looking for. I enjoyed it, but it didn’t resonate with me as much as I was expecting. So, I had taken a philosophy course that I was really interested in high school, and I didn’t think that was relevant to anything I’d be doing professionally after. It’s just purely for fun, just purely for interest, and I loved it. It was just fascinating. And so, when I was in university, I was taking a few elective courses in philosophy as well as psychology, and so I met with our high school philosophy teacher and took him out for coffee and said, “Hey, you know, I’m not sure if this biology thing is for me. Thinking about philosophy and what that might look like, and can you do anything in that other than teach and write books?” He’s like, “No, that’s pretty much it.” So, so I was like, I don’t, I don’t know if I want to do that for the rest of my life. So he asked me, like, are there any other courses that you’re taking that you’re interested in? It’s like, well, I’m taking some psychology courses. They’re, they’re kind of cool. But as a Christian, I didn’t know anybody in psychology at that point, right? I knew the Christian Counseling Center. I knew a couple of the counselors that were there, but really didn’t know if psychology was a legitimate field for Christians to get involved with, right? So, so after we had talked about it, it was really it was kind of these light bulb moments for me, where it’s seeing ways that we can take the questions of philosophy and then try to apply the scientific method to try to answer those questions, and that was what psychology was for me. So I’m like, oh, this is really fascinating. That’s kind of cool, and the part I liked about being a family doctor was not the medicine part of it as much. It was more the human connection, the coming alongside somebody in their suffering. I was like, oh, that’s 100% of what psychologists do. It is the human connection part of it. So that was like academically what really got me into psychology. From there, I just tried to get my hands on as many books in biblical counseling and Christian psychology as I could possibly get to just to try to wrestle with that a little bit from a Christian perspective because again in our community I didn’t really have a lot of people to chat with about it back in that day. So that was academically and then in my personal life just seeing the church right and I think historically the a lot of the main founders of psychology, going back to the late 1800s, early 1900s, were very anti-religion and anti-Christianity in particular. And so the church responded to that by going the opposite direction, saying, “Well, if they’re anti-church, then obviously we’re anti-psychology, right?” And so you see this really big gap and this split. That happened across churches. We’ll get into some of the nuances of the Dutch Reformed context specifically, but that’s happening generally, broadly speaking, right? So you come into when I was a teenager, when you and I were kind of growing up. I think that the culture was just starting to shift from let’s just sweep everything under the rug. Let’s not talk about it. Let’s not deal with it. Let’s not air our problems out loud. Let’s just sort of deal with it in house. The problem was that when we sweep stuff under the rug, it wasn’t going away. It was just festering, and it was growing, and it was getting worse. And so people were starting to see problems with alcoholism, anxiety, depression, you name it. And all of a sudden, we when I was a teenager was kind of like, “Oh shoot, these problems are worse than we imagine. They’re not going away. It’s not getting better.” But because we’ve been so anti-counseling for so long, we don’t have anybody from our own church background that we trust to go to for support. So, so I had to. On the one hand, I’m having sort of these academic sort of exposures, and then in church, seeing some of those cultural dynamics happening, being like, “Oh man, we really need people to step into that gap.” Somebody who has that Christian worldview, but then can also do the counseling in a more professional way to sort of meet that need. So that’s been my trajectory since my early university days was thinking about that. And for me, there’s really two main callings I’ve wrestled with: is God calling me to be the person to provide the one-on-one counseling, or is God calling me to be the person who’s going to train the next generation of counselors and have an even broader impact that way? And so now, being at Redeemer University, I’m able to kind of do both. I have Abide Psychology, my clinical practice now, so I do the individual therapy there. But then we’re also starting a new master’s in counseling program at Redeemer to train Christian counselors to counsel Christianly. And so for me, it’s exciting because I can kind of do a bit of both at the same time. So that’s my whole trajectory, and that brings me up to up to today.

TV
That’s crazy. That’s pretty rare to not have somebody or some like even a profession to model yourself after or see somebody and say, oh, like I’d love to do what that guy’s doing. But you’re really like, yeah, in a lot of ways you’re paving your own path. Like, so there’s not a lot of people… Has it grown since you’ve started getting into it? Like, since you started studying, have you seen some colleagues coming along that you know are doing what you’re doing, or has it still been pretty much you’re paving your own way?

Dr. MS
Yeah, it really feels like being a bit of a pioneer, kind of going in and blazing some new trails. But I certainly was.. I’m not the first person on the scene. I think back then it was the Christian Counseling Center, and so I’m like I’m not I can’t figure this stuff all out of my own. So the first people I talked to were Hank Vendooren at the Christian Counseling Center, and then Kevin Hoekstad. So I took them out for coffee. So that became my MO. It’s like well I just keep taking these people out for coffee. I keep paying for their coffee, then they’ll give me some wisdom, right? And just ask them questions like, hey, I’m interested in this. I’m still kind of wrestling and grappling with a lot of these fundamental questions. I know that you’re in counseling, so if you could do it over again, like, what kind of program would you apply to to train in counseling? Right? What kind of pitfalls should I look out for and kind of avoid? And you know, I don’t want to learn by trial and error myself. I can go to those kind of people, right? Outside of them, that was pretty much it back then. And so I finished my undergrad in psychology. I could talk a little bit about Eric Johnson. He’s been a huge mentor, huge impact in my life. I first encountered him through his books called Foundations for Christian Psychology, and that’s going to take me to a whole other tangent, so I’ll flag that, and we’ll come back to that at some point, I’m sure. And he had given me a lot of advice on the different range of different programs that were out there. So I that was basically what I did. Is there weren’t a lot of people, but there were a few people that I could pick their brains on.

TV
Most of the like formal education is still secular psychology.

Dr. MS
Yeah. So yeah. That’s there’s so many different things connected to this. So if I stick with my training, so I ended up going for secular training in my Bachelor of Arts in Psychology at the University of Guelph. I did my master’s and PhD at the University of Windsor, studying psychotherapy process outcome research, which is studying how therapy works and how we can make it more effective. Specifically focusing on how emotions change productively through the course of therapy. So I was gone from 2014 until 2021 before we moved back to this area again. And in between that time, it went from Christian Counseling Center, and that was pretty much it. To now we have like Insight Biblical Counseling, we have oh what Life Renewal, right? The 12 step sort of programs that, and all of a sudden it’s like there’s this explosion of all kinds of different people seeing all kinds of different needs. And we have Agape Recovery has popped up in that time span, so it’s kind of weird for me to be geographically kind of removed from the community, but then also kind of pop back in and see that for me that’s really exciting because it means that I’m not the only one seeing this need, and I’m not the only one who has the same kind of passion for trying to meet that need in a in a biblically solid sort of way, so that that’s what makes me really excited these last few years as I’m starting to network with more and more people in the area than there were when I left.

TV
Yeah, that’s cool. You definitely feel like there’s definitely more organizations, more people thinking about this this problem. But I guess let’s go back because we’re our audience is I would say primarily Dutch Reformed. I hope not all Dutch Reformed, but I mean, but that’s where we’re the context we came from, the context we grew up in. Can you talk a little bit about our Dutch Reformed culture? Like going back, what the I guess the pitfalls of you know say our grandparents’ generation, or even before that, and then where we’ve kind of landed in this world now with our generation, even younger generations, we’ll get into some of the specifics like social media and stuff. But like, can you compare how we treated mental health then and now?

Dr. MS
Yeah, I think it’s really important to take the historical context into account for a lot of these things, right? So I’m not a historian and I’m not a big history buff by nature, but if I think even about how like the Canadian Reformed Church that you and I both grew up in, how that formed. It was in 1944. Like it was during World War II that there were these doctrinal church polity issues that were coming up at that stage, and they had a church split during that time. Like if we thought COVID was rough, like you can imagine living during World War II, right? And post Great Depression and all these other sort of stuff, so that to me, it really helps me understand our context why we’re so, such a heavy emphasis on doctrine, right, and right thinking and right belief. The flip side of that, though, is that we sort of didn’t trust emotion. Emotion is fickle. It’s untrustworthy. It’s focused on ourselves, right? And so we don’t trust it, and we don’t know what to do with it, so let’s just sweep it under the rug, right? So that was, I think, there was good reasons that the culture kind of went that direction, but maybe was a little bit problem, is maybe an overcorrective to maybe throwing out emotion. So you’re growing up. So post World War II, you know, a lot of our grandparents, for you and I, you know, 50s and 60s were immigrating from Holland to Canada. So you have this really high emphasis on church and doctrine, and you’re coming over here without any money, any financial support. Pretty much, you’re coming with your bags and your basic belongings, and that’s it. You never know if you’re going to see your family again. You’re starting over from scratch with nothing, right? And so, what was the first thing they did? They set up churches and Christian schools, and a lot of them were farmers, right, and working in agriculture and just scraping by, right? So when you’re when you’re just surviving, you don’t really have the luxury to sort of navel gaze and sort of talk about, hey, how are you feeling about all this stuff? Like, I’m just trying to put food on the table. I don’t have time to reflect on any of this stuff, right? So, so I think that’s important to recognize and acknowledge just where that comes from, and what that’s about. And then you get to at least for my parents’ generation, right, their parents were again still just surviving. So again, for them, they’re still just kind of launching themselves, right? They don’t have a lot of parental support, financially or otherwise, to sort of get started. So even there, there, they’re still kind of moving from surviving to establishing, right? Then you and I come along, and now it’s like we move from establishing to thriving. And so now we have

TV
A lot more time to sit around and think about for better or worse, right?

Dr. MS
For better or worse, right? And so now I think you’ve hinted at that that maybe the pendulum has swung kind of too far the other way.

TV
I mean, our grandparents didn’t have podcasting, so that’s a good indication we’re sitting here talking about this stuff. But so they probably didn’t even have this like didn’t have this to like no one had this conversation or listen to it. Yeah, I mean, hopefully people listen to this, but it’s um yeah it’s interesting. I wonder like does it have to do with like that affluence where we have that space to I guess consider these things like consider mental health like we have all sorts of language I guess that surrounds it now, but they didn’t necessarily even have that language, have the ideas of what that was. Like, did you was there psychology back then, or was there even something we they would even call mental health, or was it not even a thing until recently?

Dr. MS
Yeah, I think, I mean, we’ve always had psychology. That’s the interesting thing: is psychology as a scientific discipline is normally pinpointed down to the late 1800s as kind of when psychology started as an academic discipline. With the establishment of Willem Fund’s research lab in Germany, that’s kind of the pivotal marking point of psychology as a science. But, I think it would be a mistake to say that psychology started there. It’s like philosophers like Aristotle have been talking about emotions and intellect and all this sort of stuff. Philosophers through Greek culture and church history. We’ve had a ton of soul care resources that the early church, all the way through church history, was developing, right? So I think it’s always been there. But the problem is when you get into the 1950s and 1960s in particular. So culturally, outside of the church, what’s happening is you have all these different new therapy approaches. So even psychology was more about giftedness testing and intelligence testing in the early 1900s. That’s where it started. There are very few psychologists; most of them are academic psychologists, not clinicians. So now you think about a clinical psychologist, and or you think about a psychologist in general. You think about a clinical psychologist, one who does counseling and mental health. That arose out of World War II. So out of World War II, we have all these soldiers returning from war with what they called shell shock back in the day, which now we call PTSD, right? And then that all of a sudden created a clinical demand for talk therapy, which Freud had started popularizing in the late 1800s, early 1900s, but never became popular until post World War II when that need arose. So then you get into the 50s and 60s, and we have all these development of all these different models. We have behavioral therapy and cognitive therapy. Carl Rogers humanistic therapy comes on the scene, right? And then again, a lot of them are very anti-religion. So up until that point, psychological problems were primarily regarded as spiritual in nature, right? That the church is the place where soul care is done, and so when the when psychology and the church split. We kind of split this psyche and psychology from the soul, from the spiritual aspect of things. And the church kind of bought into that split a little bit, saying like, “Well, if you’re going to work on the psyche and that’s a mental health problem, then we’re going to go to therapists and professionals to do that. If it’s a faith problem or spiritual problem, then the church will deal with that.” So, from the 50s moving forward, the church really gave up a little bit of that soul care responsibility that pastors were the primary counselors back in that day. So then you get Jay Adams who comes on the scene in 1970s, and he’s really an apologist for the church, saying, you know, the church is supposed to be at the forefront of counseling. We shouldn’t be outsourcing all of our counseling to the professionals. The church should have a role in that. So I really appreciate and respect Jay Adams. He’s very critical of psychology. He’s very critical of even psychiatric medications. Saying that all of that is, you know, contrary to biblical counseling, so he founded what’s called nouthetic counseling, which is very anti-psychology. So I actually agree with a lot of his critiques of psychology, but I also saw a kernel of something redeemable in psychology. There’s a kernel of truth in here that resonates with me as a human being, but also as a Christian, like they’re tapping into something real. There’s no lie that’s convincing that doesn’t have a kernel of truth in it somewhere. It’s usually a distortion of that truth rather than just an out and out lie, right? So for me, I thought that there’s something redeemable in psychology, but all the criticisms that Jay Adams were offering were valid, so I think that’s in the church where you see biblical counseling is starting to sort of come on the scene. But even that was kind of a slow growth where we didn’t have a lot of training in biblical counseling, right? And so when I was growing up, when you and I were growing up, basically the options were mostly secular programs, and then the assumption is that if you go for training in a secular program, sprinkle some Bible texts on top, then you could call it Christian, right? But the problem is, is that those a lot of those theories were developed from very unchristian worldview presuppositions that have not been critically evaluated.

TV
Meaning, like, is that is that because they separated the mind and the soul, like, and they said, well, we’re not worrying about the soul at all, or we’re dismissing that as an idea, even, and we’re saying that all your problems are physical, like in your brain, and you know we’re trying to develop a therapy to fix the brain, like yeah, the same as you would you would treat like a physical symptom in you know modern medicine or whatever.

Dr. MS
Yeah.

TV
Yeah, I guess that’s it. So like you, it’s more the starting point of where you end up. So that’s I guess why you can’t take the secular side and just sprinkle stuff on it. Are you trying? Are you trying to put the soul back into that picture?

Dr. MS
So that’s the problem, right? Is that I don’t think the soul and the psyche can be separated at all, right? I think that’s unnatural to even say that these two things could be different things, right? So psychology, psyche literally means soul. So psychology literally means the study of the soul, and so, in my secular training, that would come up once in a while. And the way that profs would respond is like, “Oh, that’s just old, outdated language. Like, we don’t think there is an immaterial soul anymore. That’s just something that we’ve just kind of borrowed culturally.” So that was a big part of it. Is they wanted nothing to do with the soul. They wanted nothing to do with religion because it was unscientific. It’s immaterial. We can’t draw any conclusion if we can’t detect it through our five senses. We can’t subject it to empirical research. Most were agnostic on it. But most psychologists are atheistic or or not religious. Wouldn’t identify as religious. So so then we go to well, it’s all biological. Then it’s all brain-based, or it’s all psychological in terms of whether it’s Freud, it’s relationships, attachment, growing up. For Rogers, it was emotion. For Aaron Beck, it was cognition. For Skinner and others, it was behavior and reinforcements of punishment and reward. Right. So, so they were all going to things that we could observe through our five senses, and excluding a priori the stuff about the soul. And so now we’re saying that’s like, well, that’s unnatural to separate that, right? So when we start with it already kind of separated, we try to put the piece back in. It’s already distorted from the outset, right? And so we got to start with an understanding of scripture, understanding of the human soul, and then build a psychology out of that.

TV
Yeah, well, that’s really good. I think that gives listeners a good picture of where like psychology is at, and how you like how you have to approach as a Christian. So, let’s move from like say our we talked about like the older generation, and then back to like I say our childhood. But what about since we’ve been growing up, like the younger kids now with social media and stuff, how have you seen, like you’ve been studying this as you’ve been watching this whole social media world unfold. Have you seen the struggles get worse, or like have the has mental health changed? Has the landscape of technology and relationships, you know, modified the way you’re looking at, like I guess what you assumed growing up was how things worked.

Dr. MS
I think it’s such a complicated question to try to answer, because then the question is like, was this stuff already there, but nobody talked about it, and now we’re just talking about it more, right? So it’s all the same. It’s just more public.

TV
I think about shell shock like that. It’s like, well, we call it PTSD. Do you define… I guess a way to approach it would be: Do you define PTSD the same as they define shell shock? Because it’s like something existed that you probably could piece apart, and now something else. Well, maybe not something else exists. The same thing exists, but then we do we layer more on top of it? Do we, because of the social media age, add things into there, or? Have we worsened the state?

Dr. MS
Yeah. So we’re… I think this is another issue, right? Is that as much as we’re talking more about mental health, it’s a bit of a double-edged sword. Um, because we could talk a little bit about concept drift, right? This whole idea that, shell shock and PTSD is very specific in terms of like a diagnostic category in terms of how it’s defined. But now trauma has become like an everyday word that people use, right? And so it’s now like okay, exposure to a life threatening event is the criterion A for PTSD. That’s capital T trauma, but now it’s like, well, if somebody commented on my outfit and it didn’t like what I was wearing, now I’m traumatized by that, right? So we’ve we have this concept drift where now it just means almost anything and everything, right? And we see that with all kinds of different therapy terminology that used to mean something very particular, but has been so watered down that now it becomes kind of meaningless, but also becomes a bit of a I don’t know if I want to say an excuse, but it can have some other problematic consequence, like gaslighting. One of those things we see all the time, right?

TV
How do you even identify the like the? I mean, yeah, you say the like the words almost drift, right? So, like, how do you, as a psychologist, or like in your clinical practice or whatever, even, how do you know you’re talking about the same thing? Like, if you say trauma and they say trauma, like, are we even on the same page anymore?

Dr. MS
So that’s where we have our diagnostic criteria in the DSM that we follow, which lists out here are all the different criteria that we’re looking for, all the different symptoms that we’re looking for. But there’s always a level of clinical judgment. So this is why I always tell my students in my abnormal psych course: beware of the medical student syndrome. You’re going to read all these lists of symptoms, and some of them are going to be things that all of us experience to some degree or another, right?

TV
Right.

Dr. MS
But we need that clinical judgment to determine whether or not this is clinically significant. So when I’m talking with clients, I’m not just giving them a questionnaire and saying, “Oh, you checked all the boxes. Oh, congratulations, you have PTSD” or whatever it is, right? It’s sort of like I ask you for examples. So like, tell me about that. Like, give me an example of a time in your life. This came up, or when this happened, and then I’m using my clinical judgment to test it out based on real examples of how that shows up in their life, and then I’m kind of making that determination about whether that’s like a clinically significant problem or if that’s just regular anxiety kind of a thing, right? All of us feel anxious from time to time. All of us should feel anxious. It’s good for us to feel anxious, but that doesn’t mean you have an anxiety disorder.

TV
Right.

Dr. MS
So that’s where I get the clinical judgment in terms of is it causing a significant amount of distress? But even more importantly, is it interfering with your functioning? Your ability to function at work or school, your ability to function in social relationships, and that sort of thing.

TV
I kind of frame it as a so the social media age a little bit in my head like but has the way that we interact now with like even texting or whatever has that changed the way we view ourselves like the way we view our mental state or like even how someone would say describe themselves to you?

Dr. MS
I think so, right? Because we hear a word and we think it means a certain thing, and so if I can resonate with it, then I don’t differentiate between anxiety as a feeling versus anxiety as a disorder, then I equate those two as being the same thing. Then all of a sudden, now I’m anxious about my anxiety, right, which actually creates more anxiety, and it ends up sort of like mushrooming and ballooning and being a self-fulfilling prophecy kind of a thing, right? And if I think about social media, like what was the classic Greek mythology around narcissus? Narcissus was looking at his reflection in the pool, and was so entranced with his own image that basically just got it totally self-absorbed, right? So that’s where you get narcissism from that narcissistic personality disorder, which is another one of those sort of manipulated, misused terms too. We get into that too, but now if I look at like our phones are literally like mirrors that we’re holding up, and we’re just constantly evaluating our lives. We’re just constantly putting everything from what I what I ate for lunch today to how I’m feeling or things that are going on, and I’m just constantly self-reflecting, not in a good way. I think self-reflection is good, but it’s almost excessive. And the problem with social media is that it’s very curated. Like I’m showing people what I want them to see of my life, not necessarily giving them a truly random sample about how things are going in my life, right?

TV
That would look like a nightmare.

Dr. MS
But it’s normal, right? It’s normal for us to our hair is a mess, the house is a mess. Like I’m kind of stressed out. I’m not doing my ideal parenting. I’m not on my A game today, right? Yeah, I think it’s norm.

TV
I think about that with dinner parties. I said that’s not even a random sampling, right? It’s like we clean up the house for that.

Dr. MS
How many hours did you spend tidying up the house and cleaning everything up, right? And so it’s a cleaned up version of our lives. So we’re comparing ourselves to our own ideal, but we’re also comparing ourselves to everybody else’s ideal and realizing that we’re not living up to either those standards, and so that gap between our perceptions of what’s normal versus our own life just widens and grows.

TV
Right.

Dr. MS
So then, of course, we think we have problems because there’s a different, but it’s not because it’s a real issue. It’s because it’s a perception of how we’re falling short compared to everybody else.

TV
Yeah and then we’re even surprised when the people that we watch in these like idealistic looking lives online have mental health struggles or have other problems, and you’re like, oh, I couldn’t imagine. It’s like, well, could you not? Like, it’s not real. Like, which is yeah, that’s super interesting. So, is that made it worsen? Like the problems, or is it just that that the dwelling on it? Our grandparents’ generation would they have struggled with the same physical disorders, but not had words to describe them, or do they not struggle with them as greatly because they didn’t have this you know this algorithm working to mess them up. I mean, they had a war, so maybe that’s worse.

Dr. MS
So it again, this is so complicated, and this is why this is such, it’s hard to have a short conversation about these things because. So I’ve got a model in my head that talks about the human person. If I go more basic, the human person is there’s a biological component to us. There’s a physical embodied aspect. If we go above that, we have a psychological and social level to it, to us. It’s our thinking, our feeling, our behaviors, and our relationships with other people. Then above that, we have the ethical, the moral right and wrong, do and do not kind of a thing. And then above that, we have the spiritual, which is more of a sense of personal connection. For Christians, it’s with God. For non-Christians, it’s at least some transcendent sense of something greater than myself. So every human has these levels built in, and all of them play a role in mental health issues. So when you ask me about like, do our ancestors have the same biological kind of problems that we do or not? The first thing that popped in my head when you asked that question was nutrition is super underappreciated in the area of mental health. That’s just starting to get some attention. Looking at the role of the gut microbiome and its impact on mood and things like that. Right, we’re so focused on the brain, and that’s where the center of our psychology is. But actually, there’s a lot going on in our physical bodies as well. So I think about all the people are starting to talk more about processed foods and the ways that nutritionally we’re not eating as balanced of a diet. We have so much more sugar and salt in our diet than we need compared to what our grandparents sort of grew up with. So even physically, their nutrition, their dietary intake, plus also the fact that they usually worked in more manual labor jobs, mean that physically, they’re probably in better shape than most of us, just by living, just by default, right? So then, then you see all the effects that that has, right? So, so yeah, of course, they still have physical problems. Sure, we could still talk about neurochemistry and that sort of stuff, but even if you think about even those more simple, simple things, so the bad news about negative emotions, negative emotions by their nature they focus they narrow our attention in. So if I’m walking in the woods and I see a bear in the woods, what do I do? Well, I feel anxious and that fight or flight response kicks in. But I zoom in my attention on the bear. I don’t care about the squirrel in the tree over there because the squirrel’s not a threat. So I zoom in on the threat, right? Positive emotions have the opposite effect, where we zoom out, we can think more creatively, more flexibly. So negative emotions make us zoom in, but they also drive us into ourselves, so that we start introspecting, we start looking within ourselves for solutions. But from again, from a Christian perspective, knowing that we’re broken, we’re going to just find more problems the more we go inwards, right? So I think one of the things that was just built into society is that when you’re working in more of an agrarian society, you’re working in community with people, it forces you to pull yourself outside of yourself. You’re focused on your work, the work of your hands. You’re focused on collaboratively working with the people that you need to work with. Now, now we do so much of our work behind computer screens that you work in a cubicle. Even when you’re working in office space with 100 people, you’re just in your box with a computer, right? And so I think that’s got to have a profoundly damaging effect in terms of just how that has impacted the way we focus on ourselves versus having a more balanced perspective, not just inwards but also outwards, and then for Christians upwards, right? Three directions, right?

TV
Yeah, man. This is yeah. We could talk about this for six hours, I think. I’m curious about the struggle. So, how do we frame our struggles? If we’re going through something, and again, we’re like we’re more introspective, let’s say, you know, these days than in the past. But how, as Christians, do we understand that, like the mind and the soul? Like, how do we understand our struggles? And is there a way for us to determine whether the thing we’re struggling with is really a disorder, or really an abnormal struggle, or can we just understand our struggles as like everyone goes through this, I just need a few people around me, and we’ll get through it, more of a temporary, or I mean… The life is full of struggle. Like, how do we how do we distinguish between those things, and does it take a professional to help us parse through them? Like, should everyone be at your door trying to, you know, clinically figure out if what they’re struggling with is, you know, diagnosable, I guess, or not?

Dr. MS
Yeah. So, in terms of diagnosis, those are the main criteria we typically look for in clinical diagnosis, is does it cause a significant amount of emotional distress, and does it interfere with their functioning in work or school or in relationships are the big areas we’re kind of looking for. That’s helpful, but we can find all kinds of exceptions to that, right?

TV
Right.

Dr. MS
So you know somebody might be an alcoholic, but it doesn’t cause them any distress, right. And oftentimes it’s their family that are the first people to say this is causing problems at your work. This is causing problems in our relationships. But you’re not upset about it. You don’t think it’s a problem, kind of, right? So, and so in other things, you know, narcissists thrive in the business world, right? So if you’re so self-focused and you’re so focused on you know climbing the ladder of success that you’re willing to climb over dead bodies and put people down just to do it, right? You actually do really well in business, right? So functioning is not a great indicator on its own, right? So these are common patterns that we see, but then I think we also have to talk about biblical norms, right? So often in in mental health, we talk about statistical norms, cultural norms – it’s a cultural deviation from what’s normal for that society and that culture. So when you and I were growing up, you know, purple hair and ear piercings and all that sort of stuff was kind of abnormal. Right. Nowadays, it’s like not that uncommon, right? You think somebody back in our day that somebody was having a big struggle or there was a big countercultural sort of message they’re trying to. Now it’s just like, you know, a mom of four kids can get purple hair, and it’s just we don’t think there’s anything wrong with her for doing it, right? So, so the culture can shift around certain things. Um, so, so what’s the biblical norm? What’s the biblical standard? And that’s going to be something that’s not going to be culturally dependent. That’s not going to be something that shifts. Um, but that’s not part of the DSM, obviously, because it’s not a Christian document. So, you talked about suffering is normal. So interestingly, as the DSM has developed, it’s gotten bigger and bigger, both in terms of like the number of pages in it, but also in terms of the number of diagnoses that are included in it. It just keeps so it expands, right? And so, interestingly, the one of the authors of DSM 4, his name is Alan Francis, was very critical of DSM 5, which is the latest edition that came out in 2013. Now, there’s a text revision that came out more recently, but he was actually very critical, and he wrote a book called Saving Normal, and he was even critical in saying that now we’re pathologizing everything, right? So now anxiety, all anxiety is now sickness, not just normal lived experience. So all of the all of the treatments in the 1950s and 60s were all about getting rid of suffering. Our whole medical system is based around getting rid of suffering, and there’s something good about that. I’m not saying that that’s wrong, but it’s maybe incomplete, right? So now you have more third wave cognitive behavioral therapies coming up, more mindfulness based approaches, which is borrowing from Buddhism, and Buddhism as a religious philosophy says that to be human is to suffer, that life is suffering, and so rather than trying to get rid of suffering, that’s actually rather than trying to get rid of pain, that’s actually where suffering comes from is our efforts to get rid of pain, and so instead we have to accept that suffering as a part of life, right?

TV
Interesting.

Dr. MS
And so that’s actually where we’re starting to see from a Christian perspective actually creation, fall, redemption, right, it’s like we’re created good, but through the fall, that we’re broken biologically, psychosocially, ethically, and spiritually, we’re broken at all those levels, and so, actually, and the creation groans us in the pains of childbirth. That right now in a post-fall world, life is suffering, and so even with redemption, that suffering can be healed, but not eradicated on the side of eternity, right? So, so there’s an acceptance piece that there’s a shift from trying to eradicate suffering, and again, we should try to alleviate pain wherever we can. But then mindfulness in Buddhism goes to accepting suffering, which is more of kind of a neutral response, not good or bad, we just have to accept it and live with it. Interesting. What I find fascinating, the Bible actually goes a step further, and it says, “Actually, have joy in your suffering.”

TV
Yeah, rejoice in it.

Dr. MS
Like, I remember reading that a few times when I was in grad school and being like, ‘Okay, is this like a one-off sort of thing? Like maybe Peter says it, but it’s kind of a Peter-ism sort of thing.’ And I started looking for it. It’s actually throughout Scripture. This is a phrase we see come up often that not only is suffering sort of bad or neutral, suffering is actually used for our good. And I don’t know about you, but if I have a migraine, I’m not rejoicing in that, right? I don’t enjoy that.

TV
Yeah, I feel like that is like that to me is just pain, and I mean you can suffer because of pain, but like I feel like suffering is like what happens to you that’s maybe unjust, or but I feel like a lot of those moments are where you learn and where you grow, and so without suffering, say like in business, for instance, or in even in your relationships, like without you know, without those moments of suffering or moments of you know critique even, it’s like you can quickly turn that into a you know I have a problem here, and I don’t know if we diagnose all those things, but that’s where you end up growing, like as a person. So to get rid of all pain or all suffering, it’s like well then we just we all end up kind of in the same place of, yeah, not really growing, not really like you’re kind of leaning on the education system to like create the friction for you to learn then, and you’re not relying on the world to be like you know put you through the fire, I guess, right?

Dr. MS
Yeah. Well, even we talk about safe spaces in school. What does that mean? Like, oh, kids should feel safe in school, of course. But what that means is, I’m not going to be exposed to any contradictory ideas, any things that challenge my core beliefs and values. Oh, that that’s not what I think of when I think about a safe space in school, kind of thing, right? Right. The university is supposed to be at this unity in diversity of ideas comes from. It was a place where you’re supposed to be exposed to all kinds of different thoughts and ideas, and then put them to the test. So, so I have all these expressions I often use. Life begins at the edge of your comfort zone. If you don’t stretch yourself beyond your comfort zone, you’re never going to grow. If anything, you’re going to stagnate and shrink, right?

TV
Right.

Dr. MS
So, so pain is not bad. Again, we don’t want to inflict pain as a way of growing. So, talk about Martin Luther and the way that he would just absolutely just whip himself and beat himself for a sin, I don’t think as Christians we would say that’s a healthy way of inflicting pain, but life is pain. We don’t have to add to it, but can we embrace the pain and use it as an opportunity for growth, not just as a way of escaping, you know, things in life, escaping pain and getting rid of it.

TV
So, have we been, have psychologists been overdiagnosing things? You talk about this this list of diagnoses growing and growing, and now is there t here is there a tendency to kind of be reining that in, or is it like is there recognition that there is over diagnosis, or?

Dr. MS
Yeah, so that’s a big debate in the field, right? So, and again, it’s not an easy question to answer because we don’t have any to answer that question precisely. We’d have to have a perfect measure of the diagnoses and compare our current measures to that perfect standard. Problem is, we don’t have a blood test or an fMRI scan or something that can say, “Oh, there’s depression.” We can we can diagnose it medically. So all of these things are kind of fuzzy, and all of these things are more immaterial, philosophical. They’re very driven by values, right? And that’s where we get Christian critiques of the DSM, but even general critiques of the DSM. So we don’t have an objective standard for truly defining a diagnosis so we’re relying on symptoms. So we’re not. So in medicine, you diagnose a disease, and you look for the symptoms to point you back to the disease, but then you have to find the disease to actually diagnose that condition. In psychology because we can’t pinpoint the actual point of disease medically and physically, then we’re left with diagnosing clusters of symptoms. So actually, diagnoses in psychology are syndromes, not diseases. But we’ve tried to we have a little bit of physics envy in psychology we talk about. We’re trying we’re trying to we’re trying to establish psychology as a scientific discipline based on a medical model.

TV
Just because you can identify those syndromes or groups of symptoms. But then you mentioned like the criteria to say to diagnose something is experiential or whatever.

Dr. MS
It’s culturally defined.

TV
And objective. So somebody, or subjective sorry. So somebody can say, well, it’s affecting my livability, my quality of life, livability. But then that could mean two wildly different things for people.

Dr. MS
Well, and we want to combine that their self-reported, their subjective experience with my observations clinically, right? So, if somebody reports that they’re often sad, do I see it? Like, are they tearful? Do they get do they get emotional really easily? That sort of stuff.

TV
But even that like because we could have wildly different emotional regulation, or even the way that we think about our emotions could be different. So, like, I might I might put a lot of stock in what my emotions say to me, and you might not, or vice versa. And so then, how do you parse that out? Because is that coming more to the surface too? Like where we’re, you talked about the old generation not um not relying on their emotion, talking about like more about doctrine, more about knowledge. Are we the other side of this, or becoming the other side of this, where we’re trusting our emotions, we’re putting more stock in what the feelings say?

Dr. MS
Every time you ask a question, I go my mind goes in like four new directions. I want to say one more thing about diagnostic over expansion, and then I’ll come back to the emotion piece. One of the critiques of diagnostic overexpansion is even in our symptom criteria. So if we look at something like ADHD, from DSM 4 to DSM 5, they increase the minimum age. So before you had to have symptoms during childhood, now they increase that limit to age 13. That symptoms had to be shown, and they reduce the number of symptoms that you need to meet criteria. So basically, they’ve lowered the bar in two different ways. So overnight, from the day that DSM 4 was published and in practice, to next day DSM 5 gets published, you have a group of people that went from being on the fringe of not quite meeting diagnosis for ADHD, and all of a sudden you change the category, you change the criteria, and all of a sudden now…

TV
Everyone’s part of it.

Dr. MS
So many 1000s of people now went from not meeting criteria to meeting criteria, not because they changed, but because our criteria changed. So we have a moving benchmark for some of these things, and that’s part of what Francis is critiquing and saving normal is that even our symptoms are becoming looser and looser. Our criteria are becoming looser and looser. So more and more pain is now becoming diagnosable, right? So now, if I go back to emotion, so if you ask somebody if you could just eliminate pain from your life. Would you do it? If you could eliminate anxiety, if you could eliminate negative emotions, would you do it? I think a lot of us would be tempted to say yes, but actually, we realize that that’s not good for us because physical pain – we put our hand on a hot stove. We don’t feel pain. We don’t take it away until we start, you know, smelling something burning. Like, oh, that’s my flesh, right? Like we have this immediate pain response to protect us from danger. Right, emotions are doing the same thing for us. They’re giving us valuable information about things that are working or not working in our life. Right. So what I would say now we’ve gone, now we’ve gone from burying our emotions to now our emotions are everything, and my core identity is what I feel. And now I would say that’s an overcorrection. So the way I would put is emotions are a gage, not a guide. The problem is that Robert Roberts defines, so he’s a Christian psychologist and philosopher, who defines emotion as a concern based construal. A construal is our perception or interpretation of something. The concern-based piece talks about what we most deeply value. So you put those two together; it’s our perceptions about what I most deeply value, and so our emotions are this very rapid, very complex system that’s sort of like a barometer of our life that’s constantly evaluating how are things going, how am I doing, and giving us immediate feedback. So emotions are densely packaged units of information. They have a physical component to them. They affect us physically in our bodies. There’s a subjective perception of what that’s about. So actors will talk about getting butterflies in their stomach, and that’s a good thing because that means they’re amped up and in the zone. When we get that before a test, we call it anxiety, and we get stressed about it. Right. So the same physiological response can mean two different things.

TV
Athletes see that too. They’re like, if you’re not nervous, then it’s no like then the stakes are not high enough. Like I want to be nervous. That’s what I’m in it for.

Dr. MS
Yeah, exactly.

TV
Interesting.

Dr. MS
Soit gives us information. So it happens immediately. We know neurologically that we feel faster than we think. So if I also see something in the corner of my eye that looks kind of like a snake, I’m having I’m starting to get scared before I even know what that is. And then I took a closer look at it. Oh, that’s just your cord for your light back there, right?

TV
Oh, right.

Dr. MS
So, so there’s actually two neural pathways in your brain: one through the amygdala, and then one through the prefrontal cortex.

TV
Otherwise a haunted house would be no fun.

Dr. MS
That’s how you can scare your kids at home, right? Right. You stand behind the door and you jump out and go boom. There’s that split second where they don’t know who you are. Cognitively, and they’re emotionally already having this fear response, and then it’s not until that second later where it’s like, “Oh, it’s just dad,” right? And then they calm down. They then they sort of hopefully laugh about it or cry about it, depending on what you’re looking for. But that’s how that works is because we feel faster than we think. So interesting. So it’s quick, but not always accurate. It’s very, very rapid, but it’s fuzzy, and then if the when the cognition comes on board, that’s where we kind of fine tune it and double check for accuracy, right? So that’s where emotions can be really helpful. Um, now I’ll give you a couple scenarios, right? So when we’ve had, I’ll say you know a decent upbringing, when our emotions, let me say our emotions are in tune with reality, if I could put it that way. Then we can actually rely on our emotions because they’re trustworthy and they’re good, right? So now, from a Christian perspective, I start thinking about: Am I thinking God’s thoughts after Him? Do I care about the same thing that God cares about? Are my values aligned with what God’s values are, or my or my emotions in line with how life actually works for real. Then we can actually listen to our emotions. We can pay attention to them. So if, I have a lot of female students in my class, so I say, you know, say you’re going on a date with this guy, and he’s like, you know, he hasn’t said anything in particular that you’re concerned about, or done anything that you can pinpoint, but you got this like spidey sense that something’s off, something’s not quite right with this guy, and then you find out you don’t go for a second date. You’re like, I’m not sure, just something’s not right, right? Then you find out in the newspaper a couple weeks later that this guy was charged with sexual assault or something like that, right? That’s happened to people before, right? They said, “I don’t know why, but at a gut level, I was picking up on something that I couldn’t cognitively kind of identify.” Right? We want to listen to those cues. Those are important cues, right? There’s actually a medical condition that causes a reduction in the amygdala, the size and the function of the amygdala. So some people, a very small percentage of people, actually don’t physically experience fear. So just like the hand on the stove example, there’s some people who emotionally don’t experience fear, and they go walking down dark alleys they shouldn’t walk down. They don’t look both ways when they cross the road, why? Because fear is telling us, be careful. Be cautious. There’s something that might be dangerous or threatening here, so take a double look, right? Keep an eye out, be on guard, kind of thing, right? If you don’t have those signals, that’s really bad for us, right?

TV
You have to cognitively get there every time.

Dr. MS
So when emotions are working well, we can actually trust them, right? So we can follow our gut intuitions, and that can be actually really helpful for us, right? In sports it’s kind of like muscle memory, right? Like the more you practice, like taking a slap shot, right?

TV
The more you can just trust it.

Dr. MS
At the beginning, you’re thinking of the mechanics of it, or playing soccer. I use this example with my clients often. How often in a soccer game do you have like you set up the pylons in a row and you dribble the ball in that? Like how often in a soccer game are all the defenders lined up in a nice neat row and you just kind of go weave your way through them? Like that never happens. But it’s practice for developing that muscle coordination so that your feet know what to do with the ball intuitively. That you don’t have to think about it. Because as soon as you have to think about it, you’re tripping over your feet. But I don’t have to think about it. Then my mind is open to focus on the play that’s happening around me. Right. I’m looking where the defenders are. I’m looking at where my teammates are, and I’m I know when the timing is for when to make a pass or when to hold onto the ball. All that cognitive space is open to focus on all those other things because my intuition, my motor, my muscle memory is doing things a little bit on autopilot, so I don’t have to think about all that stuff.

TV
Right. So how do you get to a point where you can trust your emotions? Because I mean, one of the things I’m curious about is how do you distinguish between a struggle that’s that you can, I mean, say just try to overcome, and then what? At what point, like, do we identify some of these struggles as sin? Like, let’s just say, like, let’s take anxiety. You mentioned anxiety can be a good thing to like, and I, I feel that it’s like, do you want to get rid of all pain? Not really. You want to get rid of all suffering? Not really. Like, it helps you grow. It helps you like sharpen yourself, but then the emotion of fear or whatever emotion, if you can trust it, then you can use those experiences to grow. But sometimes we can, yeah, we can, you know, I guess not understand how those emotions are sinful, or they’re not necessarily aligned with God’s word, and so they’re not indicating like you can have a conscience, but it can be either flagging you know positive things or negative things, whether you know leading you one way or the other. So how do you know, like, when, like, say, anxiety or something is you’re leaning on that as an identity too much, like, to the point where it’s like we’re not trusting God. This is probably a way bigger question. Like, people will probably be like hey but it’s not obvious to me when is it suffering and when is it like us leaning back on our sinful nature and saying, “Well, I can’t deal with this. This is you know, no.”

Dr. MS
So the short answer to that question again, we’re going in tons of my brain’s going in tons of different directions, but the short answer to that question is when our emotions no longer correspond with reality.

TV
Yeah, but what is like this is the what is reality? Yeah, people don’t agree on.

Dr. MS
Yeah. So interestingly, so many different directions. So I’ve read some articles by some early like some Christian philosophers that talked about emotions are neither objective nor subjective. So, objective is our perception of reality as it exists out there, and the subjective side is our internal perception of that reality. And so, what emotion should be doing is it should be perceiving the real object in the world in reality, and so emotions should neither be purely objective and rational, but they shouldn’t be either purely subjective either.

TV
Right.

Dr. MS
So how does this happen? So we can have broken emotions at all of those levels that I described. Right. So biologically, we talked about the amygdala. You know, we know that people who are psychopaths physically don’t experience the feeling of guilt or fear in the same way physiologically as other people. Now, does that let them off the hook? No. We’re going to get to that, right? So it can be broken at the biological level. It can also be broken at the psychological level. So, say I was sexually abused growing up. Say I’m a woman. I’m going to use the stereotype or the more common example. Young woman is sexually abused by a father figure or uncle or something like that. She’s going to learn that men are dangerous. So when she goes on that date that I described earlier, her spidey sense is going to be kicking up the whole time because she’s learned by previous experience that men are dangerous.

TV
Right.

Dr. MS
That might have nothing to do with you. You might be a perfectly nice guy, but all of my past learning and my past experience is now clouding my ability to accurately perceive you as a person. So we can no longer trust that gut sense, right? That gut intuition anymore, right? Then we go to the ethical and spiritual level. Am I perceiving things the way that God perceives things? Am I loving things in right relationship and right order? So Augustine talks about properly ordered loves, right? Am I loving – it’s good to take care of myself, right – but am I loving my neighbor as myself, right? How do I evaluate that and make that part of my emotional repertoire that I don’t just believe that. Jonathan Edwards and it talks about the religious affections. He says not just enough for us to have a stoic, purely cognitive intellectual understanding of faith. I can describe my wife in purely cognitive sort of ways. I can describe her height. I can describe her hair color. I can tell you a bit about you know the things she likes to do, but that doesn’t mean I have a relationship with her. I can describe a political leader in the same objective kind of way, but doesn’t mean I know them personally. And so, and so religious affections, and that’s a whole other thing. The word emotion is strategic as well. Affections are we think about loves, right? It’s about what we most deeply love. So it’s not just enough to know scripture. It’s do we does it change what we desire, and then are our desires in line with what scripture teaches? So it’s about our thinking, our feeling that leads to our acting, the ways that not acting in the sense of faking it, but in terms of doing, do our beliefs – do we believe our beliefs emotion at a at a at a level that we’re convicted by it? You know, the demons even have what they call speculative knowledge. Like the devil could quote scripture to Jesus, but he doesn’t believe it. He hasn’t internalized it in his heart to believe it’s true, right?

TV
Yep.

Dr. MS
Which leads to differences in our actions, right? And then that has implications for relationship. That’s psychology. I just described psychology, right?

TV
That’s a good man. We should start calling this like Mike’s hierarchy of psychology or something.

Dr. MS
So that’s the critical part is that all of these levels are important and they’re all ordered in that specific way. So biological is foundational. Basically, a broken brain means you have a broken life, right? If somebody gets in a motor vehicle accident and has profound damage to their brain, they can’t make a sophisticated confession of faith. They can’t recite question answer one, Heidelberg Catechism anymore. So somebody born with Down syndrome, right, is a genetic defect, right? That’s not a moral thing, right? That’s a biological brokenness, and yet they can demonstrate faith in ways that put many of us to shame, because of the simplicity, but the beauty and the richness of their faith, even though it’s not academically, intellectually sophisticated, It’s just a pure faith, right?

TV
Right.

Dr. MS
So now we got to go. So now I’m laying out the four orders, the four levels: biological, psychological, psychosocial, ethical, and then spiritual. Now we also have to talk about nature. Nurture is the constant debate in psychology. Am I born this way biologically, or is it from nurture, which is all my environmental experience. Bad parenting would Freud would say, right? Or bad conditioning is behaviorism. Problematic patterns of punishment, reward. On and on you go, right? Rogers. People didn’t adequately validate my emotional experiences, right? On and on it goes. And what we find from the research over and over again says it’s both. It’s not one or the other, it’s both. What’s missing in that? Personal responsibility.

TV
Not letting you off the hook.

Dr. MS
So you can have all of these things, but we still have a choice about how to respond to all those things. That choice might be fairly limited if we’ve had really profound damage in our life, if we have really few opportunities, but personal responsibility never goes to zero, right? So now we have this concept called fault, which is super helpful for me. Fault can be used in a in a geographical sense as a neutral description. There’s a fault in the ground. There’s a break. There’s a crack, right? So somebody born with Down syndrome. That’s not a moral issue. That’s a that’s a biological brokenness as a consequence of the sin of the fall. Right. So there’s brokenness that has some sort of moral roots that way. But we can’t say that because the parents sin. This is Jesus talking to his disciples. Right. Like, why was that man born blind? Was it because of his sin or his parents’ sin? And Jesus says neither is to show my glory, right? Yeah. So that was just brokenness, right? So we could talk about brokenness at the biological and psychosocial levels. That brokenness biologically, I have brokenness in my relationships, in my upbringing, brokenness in my thinking, feeling, relating, behaving, all those things, right?

TV
That brokenness – we still don’t believe that just because there is brokenness, like that, lets you off the hook for, like what we call sinful behavior. Even not even behaviors, but even sinful thinking about what’s broken. Like I, I told Mariah I wouldn’t bring this up, but actually maybe not. But this Lindsey Clancy case in the states. I don’t know if you’ve followed this or not actually

Dr. MS
I haven’t actually followed it.

TV
But this is like the this is like the crux of it is like is it your fault if you’re broken like so the whole case is like does she have a mental struggle that would preclude her from the responsibility of you know like you know not murdering her children there’s not even an argument about whether or not she did it it’s more an argument of like how responsible are you? And then, I mean, obviously, there’s social consequences, like, or you know, who is who is involved in that? Like, who should be held to account there? But like, and it could be multiple people, but like, our culture seems to want to not like want to say like it’s not your fault. So does, but as Christians, we would say that doesn’t excuse the sin. So how do we how do we you know make anything of that?

Dr. MS
So that’s the other side of it, right? So one sense of fault is purely descriptive; it’s not moral; it’s just brokenness, right? The other use of fault is in the moral sense. Like he caused the car accident; it was his fault. And then we’re getting to the ethical and spiritual sides, right? Where now there’s willfulness and intentionality and things that we do because we love ourselves more than other people.

TV
Even negligence.

Dr. MS
There’s sins of omission, there’s sins of commission and omission. Doing things we’re not supposed to do is commission. Omission is not doing the things we’re supposed to do, right? So it’s not just enough for me not to lie about my neighbor, bear false witness. We in the catechism we talk about, we actually have to promote our neighbors’ good. We have to promote their reputation, right? So there’s a negative and a positive kind of side to that. So, so the issue comes now. So you can almost think about these as two circles. I have brokenness in my biology, in my psychology, my social relationships, through no fault of my own. Especially when we talk about child abuse and that sort of stuff, we’re dependent and very powerless in those situations, right? But then we also have personal responsibility in responding to that. So now you think about these as two circles, and what happens is they actually overlap each other, and the overlap is what I’m calling fault in terms of our diagnoses. That all of our diagnoses of depression, anxiety, PTSD, alcoholism are going to fall into this mixed category, where it has elements of brokenness, but it also has elements of sin and personal responsibility. So I don’t know about that particular case. I can’t speak to that. But if I think about alcoholism, so biologically, I might be genetically predisposed disposed to alcoholism. My father was an alcoholic. A couple of my uncles and grandfather was an alcoholic. There’s a genetic wiring that that gives has gives me a propensity towards alcoholism. So that’s one piece. Psychologically, I grew up in poverty. I grew up with being abused emotionally or physically, right? You know, I’m in a bad marriage. You know, there’s a lot of conflict and stress at home. There’s a lot of work stress. On and on it goes. That’s the psychosocial kind of aspects, right? So there’s brokenness there. Now, we have to take all of those things into account. So if somebody had all those things and became an alcoholic, we’d be a little bit more understanding than if somebody had a really great upbringing. Everything was really fantastic. Everything was going super smooth and this person became an alcoholic, right? We do this in our legal system. We differentiate between willful, you know, sin. They wouldn’t call it sin, law breaking, right? And versus accidental, so first degree versus third degree murder, right? It’s sort of did you do that with forethought and intention, or was it a crime of passion in the heat of the moment, right? So we’re saying that there’s part of this that it’s not necessarily things that are our fault in the sense that we’ve willfully contributed to these things. That these are things that have happened to us. We’ve been sinned against in a lot of ways, right? But we always have a choice about how to respond to those things. So I might have all of those things, but I don’t need to pick up a bottle. The choice to pick up the bottle is something I still have at least some degree of control over. Right. So, but we need to we need to be very to be truthful and to be fair. We need to recognize that somebody’s swimming upstream against a current, and that current is flowing a lot faster than somebody else. We still expect them to swim. In the Christian life, there’s still certain ways that we’re called to and expected to live, but we’re going to be much more patient, much more gracious with somebody who has all kinds of different life factors working against them. So again, it doesn’t negate it. We don’t swing so far the other way that’s not their fault. But because sin doesn’t want to, or because society can’t talk about sin, doesn’t want to deal with sin, then it has to find some sort of explanation to get rid of personal responsibility. And yet, what I here’s another tangent. That we’re not going to go down. I think about critical race theory. Super complicated. I have a lot of critiques of it, a lot of concerns about it because it’s very destructive. It’s all about deconstruction rather than construction. So there’s a lot of things we could talk about there. But what one of the fascinating things for me is that society is starting to talk about sin again at a popular level. Now we call it racism and discrimination, right? But it’s like, oh, now people are realizing that there’s a moral sensitivity that people have, right? So there’s huge problems with that. But all of a sudden, I think there’s things happening socially that now moral responsibility in research. They’re starting to do more research on virtues, right, which was regards a philosophical to value laden for us to deal with scientifically.

TV
I feel like that’s a little bit of a crumbling of that atheism, like the modern atheist kind of worldview, where there you see a lot of people peeling off that, where it’s like actually that’s not grounded in anything. People are realizing that’s not has no moral basis, like they can’t justify it with anything. So interesting, yeah. So where, so how do you with this like contrast between like this the sinful, like we can be doing sinful things, or we can be leaning on sinful, leaning on these disorders or even struggles in a sinful way. How do you see as a psychologist the devil playing a role? Like because we’re fighting our own flesh in a lot of ways, but the devil’s also using these even culturally. Like I mean, like even with social media or how these things come at us. But how do you see the devil working in that and in us, to influence us to make poor decisions, and what might those even be like?

Dr. MS
Yeah, so I think the devil is not creative. The devil is destructive. So what I was saying earlier about lies usually lies are not full out lies. Not if they’re convincing, anyway, right? Usually, it’s a distortion of something true. So, if I go right back to the garden, right? What did Satan say? Like Satan appealed to Eve’s sensibilities when she saw that the fruit was pleasing to the eye and good for food and good for making one wise, that was what tempted her into actually eating the fruit, right? So, are all of those things bad that the fruit itself had good desirable properties to it that had appeal at a biological level or for wisdom or things like that? No, that’s not in itself bad. It was bad because he took those good things and he twisted it and distorted it to directly contradict what God had commanded them to do or not to do. Right. So I think that is the MO, the modus operandi, that the devil uses is often using our sensibilities, using real things and distorting them and twisting them. Right. So I could talk about anxiety, right? Anxiety drives us inwards, and we’re just naval gazing, and we get more and more lost. Now I think about another fascinating story for me is Peter walking on the water, right? So Jesus walking on the water to the boat. For me, this is fascinating because I remember this is a familiar story to us, right? And often in my memory as a kid, I always imagine it’s a bright sunny day, right? There’s the blue skies, and Jesus is just kind of like casually walking on the water. But then you kind of reread it, and you’re like, “No, there’s a storm.” Like Jesus walking on the water, it’s dark, there’s big waves, right, and all that sort of stuff, right? And then Jesus calls him onto the water. First of all, if I’m Peter, I’m not even stepping out of the boat, right? Yeah. So we give we give Peter a hard time, but for me, it’s remarkable he had enough faith to even do that. But then it’s interesting. He steps out onto the water, and then then there’s a very tiny mention that says, and then Peter saw the wind, like that’s a really tiny detail. But it’s like he looked to his external circumstances. He took his mind off of Jesus and started looking to his circumstances, and they were real. Those were real waves. And notice you can’t see wind; you can only see the effects of wind, right? So, so he was responding to a very real threat, but the problem is he took his eyes off of Jesus, who said, “I’m going to be your anchor in the midst of the threat.” So I think this for me is where we got to be very careful with reductionism. We don’t reduce anxiety down to one particular thing. It’s not a neurochemical imbalance only in your body. That could be the case for some people, right? It’s not only nurture. It’s not only your upbringing, your psychology, all that sort of stuff. It’s not only a faith issue. It’s probably all of the above in different degrees and in different mixes. So when the Bible even gives the command of “Do not be anxious,” I can’t remember the stats on this. I remember a book on biblical counseling talked about this. 90 plus percent of the Bible texts that say “Do not be anxious,” very close in proximity to that command is an imperative or is an indicative. I’m mixing them up. Is a description of God, right? And is saying that “Do not be anxious, for I am with you.” It’s not a command about like, “Don’t be scared, just stop it.” That means like you got to shut off your human biology. Like, don’t be scared, Peter, of looking at the waves. Like just don’t react to that. Like how could you not? Right. It’d be very unnatural. It’s not about not being afraid. It’s about setting our eyes on Him. Right. So do not be afraid, for I am with you. I am greater than this threat. I am greater than this problem. Right. So I think so much of anxiety is so much of us seeing very real threats, but hyper fixating on the threat and subtly forgetting that God is here. That God is sovereign. That nothing happens outside of his control. That there’s no temptation that’s not common to man. That he is always working all things for the good of those who love him, even if we can’t understand and see that good. And if we subtly forget that, then we focus so much on our real problems that the anxiety starts taking over and runs amok. Right. And that’s why we always have to be reminding ourselves to go back. Remember that God is with us, but not to the point where God wants us to dismiss and discount the fact that there’s real problems in our lives. We can deal with them realistically with God at our side, not by ourselves.

TV
Yeah, yeah, that’s a good that’s a good way to put it. So let’s talk about treatment, I guess, because we’re running out of time. But we, I mean, we think we could chat for hours. But the so the counseling side, often we say things like, “You should find professional help for that.” What I guess role does a professional counselor play? Whether like whatever their the struggle and whatever the therapy might be, and then what role do we play as like friends, family, a church community, even pastors? Like, is there place for that? And then how do we know, I guess when a struggle should be elevated to a, well, a professional, or should we even talk like that? Like, can you give any guidance on you know, other than go see Mike because you know he likes to help you?

Dr. MS
Yeah. No, it’s a great question and one that I think there’s so much untapped potential in our churches to meet the mental health and spiritual needs of people in our churches that we haven’t fully realized yet. We’re just starting to with a lot of these programs that are coming up. For me, it’s not an either or. So we go back to the splitting of the psyche from the soul, right? Our mental life from our spiritual life. It’s not an either or. So I could I could use a personal example real quick. I did my predoctoral internship, a one year clinical placement at Western University in London, Ontario during 2020 to 2021. If you remember what was happening in that time, there was this virus that that went around called COVID. And so, my cohort, there was there was a group of other people that we were all working on this internship together, we had people that were traveling from as far away as Saskatchewan and Nova Scotia that came to London to do their internship there. And when we moved to London, right away, the first week or two of us moving there, we were starting to go to church, obviously as we do as Christians, right? And very quickly we started to establish relationships. We met other families with kids the same age, all that sort of stuff. We got plugged in pretty quickly, even though half of our time in London that year was in lockdown. So even there were times that a lot of our time was in you know watching services online rather than being physically in person with people. But still, we had been able to develop relationships in that context. Those peers who had come from other either side of the country, they were literally living in an apartment by themselves, and couldn’t go out, couldn’t socialize with anybody, and it was a struggle for them. And they’re looking at me, being like, “How the heck did you meet people so quickly? How the heck do you have all these connections?” We’re like, “Church?” Like, like it sounds so simple, but it’s like I think we take that for granted that the secular psychology world is really struggling with mental health funding. That most people can’t afford professional therapy. The government refuses to cover therapy with OHIP to treat as another health services like our medical services to cover costs for that. So there’s this huge gap. It’s like if you don’t have that in your immediate family or your social network, then you have a professional, and there’s no way in between. Even some of our programming publicly, there’s a there’s a program. I did my research on my PhD research on anger, and there’s anger management programs in Windso that people wouldn’t qualify for unless they also had a drinking problem. So it’s like you’re in this in between zone. So you’re not broken enough…

TV
That seems like an encouragement.

Dr. MS
Yeah. So you’re not broken enough to qualify for our program. So we’ll wait long enough for you to be broken enough, and then you’ll then you’ll qualify for services.

TV
That’s a broken system.

Dr. MS
Yeah. It’s a hugely broken system, but nobody has a solution for it, right? So now we go into the church, and what I love about the church is this isn’t an either or thing anymore, right? It starts from the ground up, right? So at baseline, one of the more the more contentious things I like to poke people with is I think sermons off the pulpit should be group therapy. Now, what do I mean by that? I got to be careful. I got to qualify. What I mean by that, because sometimes people, when I say that, think that I mean that sermons are meant to just make us feel better about ourselves. If you think that’s what I mean, you don’t know what therapy is. I get paid to make people cry, so it’s you poke people, you convict people, you go into hard things and painful things. So, so the preaching right off the bat should not just be an academic theological exercise. It should also be something that the word speaks into our hearts, into our daily lived situation, and that’s not always the application that that the minister is making. It’s just the word speaking in honestly and truthfully because it’s real. Guess what? It is real, right? So, so I write from that level. It starts with you know the preaching. Then we go into our small group Bible studies where we start digging into a topic. And here’s another cultural thing. When I was growing up, when you and I were growing up, should I say this publicly? We’re being recorded, right?

TV
Oh yeah, big time.

Dr. MS
It’s real talk, right? We’re allowed to do real talk. So often, all of us, we went to Christian church. We went to Christian school, and so we’d have young people’s Bible studies, and everybody knew what the right Sunday school answer was to all the questions.

TV
We were learning them.

Dr. MS
So we all knew what the right answer was, but we never made it permissible for people to talk about their struggles, there’s this head heart disconnect, right? Where it’s like, I know this is true, but I’m really struggling to live that out. If I’m really honest with you, right? Like, there was never that space in young people’s Bible study to like you don’t talk about that because then…

TV
That’s because we’re only we’re only third generation Dutch Reformed, right?

Dr. MS
So, so yeah, through different Christians I’ve met in in different cultures, I want to say like the there’s some solid Reformed Baptists, friends that we made in Windsor that that we got to know well, and their Bible studies they were so good at just being like, okay, here’s the biblical truth, and here’s my struggle with it, and it’s like, oh man, we if we just take the lead in doing that, that’s where I think Life Renewal is on that trajectory. Is trying like, okay, let’s talk about struggles. Let’s not just talk about the Bible abstractly, but let’s talk about where it meets us in our struggles. Right?

TV
Do you feel like that, just a little bit of a tangent, but do you feel like that that Life Renewal programs that, and so like if you don’t join life renewal, you don’t get that, and it’s turning it into a bit more of a formal, a therapeutic environment. And or would you rather see it spring up more naturally, like you mentioned in our culture of our churches, in our Bible studies, in just our relationships?

Dr. MS
I’d say both. I would say start naturally. So I’m working from the bottom up, from like the least severe problems. Like all of us have brokenness in our lives that can be addressed through the preaching, right? This should be normalized in our Bible studies. I think life renewal is the next level above that, where it’s like, okay, now I’m coming because I have a problem.

TV
Oh, okay.

Dr. MS
I’m not coming because I want to deepen my understanding of the word, and then my problems kind of show up in that context. Now it’s reverse. I’ve got a problem, and now I want the Bible to speak into that problem situation with other people encountering problems. So that’s another level. So now we have. I would I would put that in the category of lay counseling. These are not professionally trained counselors. These are some people, and I love the biblical counseling movement’s emphasis on the importance of training members in our community with some introductory training just to meet people with regular day to day struggles. We know from the research that lay counseling is just as effective as professional counseling for a lot of those more mild to moderate kind of problems, which is fascinating to me. Why is that? So there’s one of my favorite therapy stats is that 30% of outcome in therapy is due to the therapeutic relationship, trusting your therapist, having a warm bond, agreement on the goals of therapy, the outcomes, and then agreement on the tasks, the strategies to get to those goals. That’s 30% of outcome in therapy. Specific interventions and techniques are 15%, exactly half.

TV
And you’re wondering why you went so much schooling.

Dr. MS
Well, well, part of it is that we get we get trained in how to develop strong therapeutic relationships and that sort of thing too, right? So it it’s not that the training is worthless or meaningless, but the flip side is that I’ve met so many Christians are like I’m so afraid of saying the wrong thing because I know somebody’s depressed or they’re struggling with this or that. I don’t want to say the wrong thing. So what they do is the person who’s depressed is already withdrawing, right? And then the people that could help them are withdrawing because they don’t want to say the wrong thing. So well intended, but they’re more and more isolated as time goes.

TV
That’s where we have this like you should find professional help because it’s more like I don’t know what to do.

Dr. MS
So that could be the case, but I think there’s even a middle ground there with lay counseling where it’s like I don’t know how to help you. I don’t. I can’t. So this is another part of our Dutch culture is that we are very driven to fix problems, solution focused. We don’t know, especially men, but also Dutch people. So I struggled this this a long time. It’s like we don’t know how to just sit and listen and say I don’t know, but I’m going to sit with you in it. And we’re going to pray about it, and we’re going to take it to the one who does know. And I’m not going to offer you solutions, but that really sucks.

TV
And doing that just helps.

Dr. MS
Even that is powerful. I can’t tell you how many clients I work with outside the church, but even within the church, that feel like they don’t have a single person in their life that they could do that with. And so when I’m as a professional working with that person, we get like a huge one hour mega dose of compassion and care and love, and then they go out into the rest of their life, and it’s just a vacuum, or it’s actually negative messaging that it’s like one step forward and three steps back based on everything else they’re getting in their church context or their relationships, right? So I, as a professional, can’t do it by myself, right? The client can’t do it only in professional therapy. It has to be the whole spectrum and continuum. So, so I don’t want to call out Life Renewal specifically, but I think there’s limits to what Life Renewal can do. It’s structured, it’s organized, it’s problem focused, and I think that is super helpful above just a Bible study sort of thing. But it normalizes the culture. It’s like, hey, guess what? We’re all broken sinners. Like, church is not supposed to be a museum where we hold ourselves up as having it all fixed and figured out and perfect. Church is supposed to be a hospital where we’re all coming with the recognition that we’re sick, right? Um, so, so we’re acknowledging that Life Renewal is acknowledging that, but there are some things that are just too deep and too complicated that a 12-step program it’s packed. I’ve been through the program before. It’s super dense and it moves super fast. That you’re not going to be able to catch all the nitty-gritty intricacies, especially of complex trauma, abuse, those sort of things going on. That’s where you need the more focused, intentional one-on-one. So I see all this as a spectrum, and I see it as things that are all complementary in terms of working together. That if we had some of these lower pieces, we could probably off-ramp people before it ever got to escalate to the professional level, right? So some people there’s going to always be a certain segment of people that are going to need that professional level of help, but there’s a ton of good that we’re only just barely starting to tap into in that mid range within our churches.

TV
Wow! Yeah, I feel like we could do a we should we should have Mike back on and we should do this with a biblical counselor and talk about this this care side of it because I feel like there’s a lot we can do in our churches. I feel like as Dutch Reformed we try to program everything we try to we try to think of like oh again like to this solution-based model, it’s like okay, well, there’s a problem. What’s the solution? The solution’s a program. And then but there’s just so much in this world. Or we say okay, well, you don’t quite qualify for that program. We’re doing the same thing as this this anger management group is, where it’s like, well, okay, you don’t really have problems you need solved, but we all have like things that we can contribute to each other, and just like what do healthy relationships look like, and what it how do we create a culture around it without going too far? Because it’s a it’s a thing that you know..

Dr. MS
And I love our church community, right? Like God said, it’s not good for man to be alone, and throughout Scripture, He commands us to be in relationship with each other’s iron sharpens iron. We need each other. When I was in Chatham and I was going through my PhD program, we would stay for lunch in between church, and there was a an elder, an elderly man in the church who was a long term elder in the church. He’s a farmer. Another guy who’s middle age who’s a truck driver, and every week we would be having conversations over soup, and every single time, not every single time, but often, they would say like, “I’m just a simple farmer. I’m just a simple truck driver. I don’t, I don’t have all the training and knowledge and education you have.” I’m like, “No, no, like you have a lot of wisdom.” Like I love talking with you because you see things from a different perspective and a different angle, and you’ve had a lot of different life experience. And I didn’t see myself as being like one up above them because I had more letters behind my name. I was like, you guys, you guys have a certain level of wisdom and experience that I really love and I really appreciate. And so for me, it’s not about being the wise guru on the mountaintop who everybody goes to for this wise sage advice. Actually, that created a lot of anxiety. For me, as a beginning therapist, feeling other people expected that of me. No, I’m in the trenches with you. I got the dirt under my fingernails, just like Jesus entered into our suffering with us. I’m in it with you. I don’t have all these things figured out, but I know I know some things. I know how people generally work. You’re the expert in your own life experience, and we’ll just keep deepening, using this as an opportunity to deepen your faith in God and go to Him, trust in Him, lament, surrender things to God. Like those are active responses. Those feel passive, or like we’re not doing anything about it, right? And we’re not fixing it. But it’s like those. That’s an active thing that we have to do is to bring these things before God.

TV
Yeah. Oh man, I yeah, I wish we weren’t out of time. We should we should have you back and talk about what you’re doing at Redeemer and all the research you guys are doing and kind of creating a like a model of how to do this in a Christian way.

Dr. MS
Yeah, I would love to.

TV
Yeah, Mike, I really appreciate it. This has been great. Thanks for having me. Learned a lot and hope everyone enjoyed that. And I feel like this is a episode that we can listen to over and over again because it’s just every time you think through these things, you have a bit of a different context and different relationships even and learning how to help people is you know never a story that just ends.

Dr. MS
Progressive sanctification. It’s something that we’re all working towards.

TV
Yeah, so you set off on a goal to help people. So I think you’ve you might have achieved that, but you know, keep it up.

Dr. MS
Yeah, no, and I appreciate it. I think that’s this is great opportunity for me too to even you know have an impact at the church level, right? The grassroots level, and you know through these podcasts and through these conversations, be able to be in people’s speakers in their car while they’re driving, or wherever it is, and to hear that you know there’s lots of ways that the church can really come alongside and support people with struggles.

TV
Awesome. Dr. Strating, I like that. Thanks so much. Thanks everyone for listening. We’ll catch you next time. Keep having Real Talk.

Categories: ,

By clicking the checkmark, you accept and acknowledge that you have read and understand our Cookie & Privacy Policy