Transparent heart icon with white outline and + sign.

Life's busy, read it when you're ready!

Create a free account to save articles for later, keep track of past articles you’ve read, and receive exclusive access to all RP resources.

White magnifying glass.

Search thousands of RP articles

Equipping Christians to think, speak, and act

Open envelope icon with @ symbol

Get Articles Delivered!

Equipping Christians to think, speak, and act delivered direct to your Inbox!

A A
By:

How we evaluate books

There are a trillion books out there, and that means, even while most of them are bad, there are piles and tonnes and mountains of super fun, important, cute, beautiful, hilarious, educational, gripping, and otherwise great books out there somewhere, just waiting to be discovered.

So here at Reformed Perspective is where we’re talking about all those great ones.

Now, even among Christians, ideas will differ as to what makes a book great. It’s not all relative, so we’re looking at these through a Christian lens to evaluate what is praiseworthy (Philippians 4:8) with a particular emphasis on steering clear (with only the rarest of exceptions) of anything that takes God’s Name in vain. But there certainly is going to be a degree of taste involved. No one will like every book recommended here, but we do believe that every one of them will be loved by someone.

A good 3/4 of the books here are for kids, and because there are so many great kids’ books out there, our standards are high. If your standard is even higher, we hope we can still serve you, because, regardless, our goal is to never leave a parent surprised. So where there might be concerns – potty humor, other language, bad behavior, and worldview concerns (evolution, libertarianism, individualism, godlessness, etc) – we’ll note it, so you can judge for yourself whether it’s a book you’ll want to share with your kids.

While we’re looking for what’s excellent, we can’t escape the reality that we live in a fallen world, so even the best book may have bits that we wish it didn’t. That’s where judgment comes in. We’re not going to pitch Captain Underpants, no matter how hard it might make little boys laugh, because of its juvenile humor. But we have recommended Sir Ladybug and the Bookworms, even though it has a dung beetle as a character and consequently has a touch of potty humor. Why? Because we found the sweet story reason enough to overlook a pinch of the juvenile. So, how much potty humor is too much? It’s a judgment call.

With teen and adult books, we tolerate more objectionable content (though still note it) so long as the book gives us a reason to – ie, there has to be something especially educational, insightful, important, or simply awesome. For example, we’ve done a brief review of Brave New World and 1984 even though both include sexual content, because both remain especially impactful books in our culture, so Christians should be reading and understanding them.

It’s also worth a mention that among the books we’re recommending here, not all are equally… substantive. There are some titles that could be best categorized as candy – fun, lightweight, and great as a treat, but not good for you if that’s all you’re eating. Others are meatier, giving a reader something they can grow on, but perhaps taking some effort to chew through. And then there are all sorts of books that fall somewhere in between.

The world often talks of reading as if it should be done for its own sake. But our goal in all our recommendations is to point God’s people to books that they can enjoy and appreciate while honoring Him. It’s reading, to the glory of God!

Have any book suggestions? We’d love to hear them – contact the editor here. Interested in writing up the review yourself? Feel free to pitch your idea to the editor, and read our book review tips and guidelines here.

Enjoyed this article?

Get the best of RP delivered to your inbox every Saturday for free.



Red heart icon with + sign.
Christian education

Rating books for the school library

Having just reviewed Escape From the Killing Fields (by Nancy Moyer) for the senior section of our Christian School Library, I thought it would be a good book to use to illustrate how a volume, which has its definite downside, can still remain on the shelves and, hopefully, teach young readers in the process. The story Ly Lorn, brought up in Cambodia, was a teenager when the Kmer Rouge took over. Dispossessed of her city home she was forced to flee, together with her large family, into the Cambodian countryside. Living in a one-room hut, and compelled to work brutally long hours at hard labor, she watched all her siblings and parents die, with the exception of an older sister. Lorn had the advantage of having worked for World Vision at which place workers had introduced her to the Gospel of Jesus Christ. Brought to a baby faith in Christ, she, from time to time throughout the book, confesses trust in Him. It is rather confusing, however, to read Lorn's separate accountings of her family member's deaths. They are Buddhist but she does not seem unduly concerned about their afterlife. On the contrary, death is depicted as peaceful and as a place away from the atrocities of the present. The historic pages of Cambodia's holocaust are graphically and realistically portrayed as man's inhumanity to man. Lorn's story, and the story of her fellow Cambodians, is one of much weeping but also one of hope. In the end, she and her sister safely arrive in the US and are helped by a host of loving people. Given shelter they now have the option to worship freely the God Who has delivered them from bondage. There is no clear, happily ever after in the Lord, however. Lorn submits to and desires a traditional marriage. She lets others (an uncle and an aunt) choose her spouse. Nothing is mentioned about whether or not the man is a Christian and his attributes are mainly that he is a hard worker and, later, a good father. Lorn also, again in the last chapter, inflates the work ethic, the importance of education and the possibility of her children attaining well-paying jobs. She even goes so far as to say that it is too much for her to attend church regularly - a depressing statement in view of the turn her life has been given. The paste-up With regard to these rather negative overtones creeping throughout the pages, a short write-up has been pasted into the book. This write-up will be pointed out to the older children checking it out of the library. It is a wise parent who monitors his or her child(ren)'s books. This particular book, for example, can lead to fruitful discussions and much introspection as to whether or not we appreciate our religious freedom enough. Who knows what tomorrow will bring to Canada? The write-up pasted into Escape from the Killing Fields reads as follows: There are a number of things to keep in mind as you read this book. Learn that the history of Cambodia's last few decades is very sad and horrifying. Note that Lorn's story illustrates God's grace. She is shown that salvation is only in Jesus and her life is spared. Remember that Lorn is a very young Christian who (as yet) has very little knowledge of what God teaches in His Word. You see this in the way she speaks of her family's death. You also see it in the way she marries (not using Biblical guidelines for choosing a Christian husband.) You continue to see it in the way she seems to count (in the last chapter), possessions, education and job security as very important. Church attendance, on the other hand, as well as Bible study, appear to be secondary. Do speak with your Mom and Dad about what you've read....