by Shirley Hughes
48 pages / 2003
Rating: Good/Great/GIFT

This unique spin on the story of Cinderella is so good it improves on the original. Some of that is due to Shirley Hughes’ artwork, charming as always. Then there is the setting: this is a “Jazz-Age Cinderella” pushing the story forward to the 1920s. Ella and her father run an elegant dress shop, making the finest of clothes. The evil stepmother, in this case, has some business acumen, turning the small shop into an even bigger success. But the greater the demand, the more work there is to do for poor Ella.

The story follows along the familiar course of other Cinderella versions, but with pictures all the more stunning, and a twist at the end in which (SPOILER ALERT!) the love-at-first-sight duke finds his Ella but doesn’t get the girl! This is really what sets this version both apart and above all others – none of the nonsense about knowing someone for an evening and then getting married when next you meet again. Nope, Ella ends up with the store’s delivery boy, who has always been there for her and wanted to be so evermore.

While Hughes’ artwork is wonderful, the prose is superb as well. It flows so very naturally that, as I read this out loud to my girls, I felt as if I was one of those professional readers. I sounded good! But that is all to Hughes’ credit, and not my own – there is a wonderful flow to each page of text.

I will add one caution: there is one use made of the term “good heavens,” which some view as a substitute oath and too much like a real blasphemy for their liking. Though I don’t agree, I do sympathize and wanted to alert readers to its use.

I would give this two very enthusiastic thumbs-up, and recommend it highly to anyone who has three- to ten-year-olds. While this is probably far more a girl than a boy book, I really liked it. I think other dads will enjoy reading it too.

And if you’re looking for another inventive spin on Cinderella, be sure to check out Jan Brett’s Cinders: A Chicken Cinderella.